Which one should you use: recording, editing, or sharing?
The best format depends entirely on what you plan to do with your footage. Different stages of the video production process favour different strengths, so understanding your primary workflow helps you make the right choice from the start.
Editing and sharing your footage
For most editing workflows, MP4 offers clear advantages. Its single-file structure simplifies importing footage into editing software — you simply locate the file and bring it into your project. There's no need to navigate folder hierarchies or ensure index files remain intact.
MP4 files also tend to process faster during editing because the simpler container structure requires less overhead. Scrubbing through footage, applying effects, and rendering previews all benefit from this efficiency.
When it comes time to share your finished work, MP4's universal compatibility shines. You can upload directly to any social platform, embed video on websites, send files via email or cloud storage, and trust that recipients can play your content without special software. Smaller file sizes at equivalent quality levels mean faster uploads and downloads.
Adobe Premiere Pro supports both AVCHD and MP4 natively, so you're not locked into either format during editing. You can import AVCHD footage shot on a camcorder, edit it in Premiere Pro, and export a finished MP4 for distribution. This flexibility lets you work with whatever source material you have while delivering in the most practical format for your audience.
Archiving and Blu-ray playback
AVCHD still holds value in specific scenarios. If you're creating content specifically for Blu-ray disc distribution, AVCHD's native compatibility with Blu-ray specifications streamlines the authoring process. The format was literally designed for this purpose, and that heritage remains useful for certain professional and enthusiast applications.
Some videographers prefer AVCHD for archival purposes because the format's strict specifications ensure long-term compatibility with Blu-ray hardware. If you're building a library of footage that you want to play directly on Blu-ray players years from now, AVCHD provides that assurance.
Legacy compatibility also matters in some situations. Older HDTVs and media devices that predate widespread MP4 support may handle AVCHD more reliably. If you're working within an established ecosystem of older hardware, sticking with AVCHD avoids potential playback issues.
That said, for the vast majority of users, MP4 is the practical choice. Unless you're specifically shooting 1080p content destined for direct Blu-ray burning, MP4's flexibility and compatibility outweigh AVCHD's niche advantages. Modern archival strategies increasingly favour widely supported formats that won't require specialised hardware to access decades from now.